#127844: "A few suggestions from the designer and publisher"
Sobre qué é este informe?
Qué aconteceu? Por favor selecciona debaixo
Qué aconteceu? Por favor selecciona debaixo
Por favor revisa se xa hai un informe sobre o mesmo tema
De ser afirmativo, por favor VOTA por este informe. Aos informes con máis votos se lles da PRIORIDADE!
| # | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
|---|
Descrición detallada
-
• Por favor, copia e pega a mensaxe de erro que ves na túa pantalla, se houbera algún.
Great work overall, this is a super smooth and intuitive interface. Really nice!
Some thoughts:
- In the real game I encourage players to keep Agenda cards in their hand because otherwise I find they often forget that they have them. In fact, in this implementation, the button to reveal is a bit hard to find initially, and players will likely forget that they even CAN reveal. Players are much more focused on the trick-taking and choosing a card to play, rather than thinking about revealing. So, since they're staring at their hand anyway, I suggest Agenda cards could go in hand here too, with a "reveal" button (as well as a "rotate" button so you can rotate the agenda even if you don't reveal) appearing above the Agenda card at the start of your turn. The face-down Agenda is still next to the player board, and once revealed, it is removed from your hand and flips over, indicating that you have made it visible to others.
- In this top-down 2d implementation, it's a bit difficult to see where the plugs are connected. I would love to see a yellow cable line connecting the plugs (this can be a simple graphic overlay) so that it's super clear at a glance which appliances are connected.
- The phrasing "You must select a plug to receive 1⚡ from another plug" is a bit confusing. I suggest rewording it to: "You must select a plug. It will receive 1⚡ from the other plug."
- The card icons in the opponent hand are very small, and I think could be a bit larger.
That's it, everything else is wonderful! So many great little details too, like how the spy cards are arranged on the back side so players think they're hidden, but on the front side they are set apart so you can easily distinguish them. Top notch. -
• Por favor, explica o que querías facer, o que fixeche e o que pasou
• Cal é o teu navegador?
Google Chrome v125
-
• Por favor, copia/pega o texto amosado en inglés no canto do teu idioma. Se tes un pantallazo deste erro (boa práctica), podes usar Imgur.com para subilo e copiar/pegar a ligazón aquí.
Great work overall, this is a super smooth and intuitive interface. Really nice!
Some thoughts:
- In the real game I encourage players to keep Agenda cards in their hand because otherwise I find they often forget that they have them. In fact, in this implementation, the button to reveal is a bit hard to find initially, and players will likely forget that they even CAN reveal. Players are much more focused on the trick-taking and choosing a card to play, rather than thinking about revealing. So, since they're staring at their hand anyway, I suggest Agenda cards could go in hand here too, with a "reveal" button (as well as a "rotate" button so you can rotate the agenda even if you don't reveal) appearing above the Agenda card at the start of your turn. The face-down Agenda is still next to the player board, and once revealed, it is removed from your hand and flips over, indicating that you have made it visible to others.
- In this top-down 2d implementation, it's a bit difficult to see where the plugs are connected. I would love to see a yellow cable line connecting the plugs (this can be a simple graphic overlay) so that it's super clear at a glance which appliances are connected.
- The phrasing "You must select a plug to receive 1⚡ from another plug" is a bit confusing. I suggest rewording it to: "You must select a plug. It will receive 1⚡ from the other plug."
- The card icons in the opponent hand are very small, and I think could be a bit larger.
That's it, everything else is wonderful! So many great little details too, like how the spy cards are arranged on the back side so players think they're hidden, but on the front side they are set apart so you can easily distinguish them. Top notch. -
• É este o texto dispoñible no sistema de tradución? Se é así, foi traducido fai máis de 24 horas?
• Cal é o teu navegador?
Google Chrome v125
-
• Por favor explica a túa suxestión de maneira precisa e concisa para que sexa o máis sinxelo posible entender o que queres dicir.
Great work overall, this is a super smooth and intuitive interface. Really nice!
Some thoughts:
- In the real game I encourage players to keep Agenda cards in their hand because otherwise I find they often forget that they have them. In fact, in this implementation, the button to reveal is a bit hard to find initially, and players will likely forget that they even CAN reveal. Players are much more focused on the trick-taking and choosing a card to play, rather than thinking about revealing. So, since they're staring at their hand anyway, I suggest Agenda cards could go in hand here too, with a "reveal" button (as well as a "rotate" button so you can rotate the agenda even if you don't reveal) appearing above the Agenda card at the start of your turn. The face-down Agenda is still next to the player board, and once revealed, it is removed from your hand and flips over, indicating that you have made it visible to others.
- In this top-down 2d implementation, it's a bit difficult to see where the plugs are connected. I would love to see a yellow cable line connecting the plugs (this can be a simple graphic overlay) so that it's super clear at a glance which appliances are connected.
- The phrasing "You must select a plug to receive 1⚡ from another plug" is a bit confusing. I suggest rewording it to: "You must select a plug. It will receive 1⚡ from the other plug."
- The card icons in the opponent hand are very small, and I think could be a bit larger.
That's it, everything else is wonderful! So many great little details too, like how the spy cards are arranged on the back side so players think they're hidden, but on the front side they are set apart so you can easily distinguish them. Top notch. • Cal é o teu navegador?
Google Chrome v125
-
• Qué había na pantalla cando se quedou bloqueado? (mensaxe de erro?, pantalla en blanco?, unha parte da interface do xogo?)
Great work overall, this is a super smooth and intuitive interface. Really nice!
Some thoughts:
- In the real game I encourage players to keep Agenda cards in their hand because otherwise I find they often forget that they have them. In fact, in this implementation, the button to reveal is a bit hard to find initially, and players will likely forget that they even CAN reveal. Players are much more focused on the trick-taking and choosing a card to play, rather than thinking about revealing. So, since they're staring at their hand anyway, I suggest Agenda cards could go in hand here too, with a "reveal" button (as well as a "rotate" button so you can rotate the agenda even if you don't reveal) appearing above the Agenda card at the start of your turn. The face-down Agenda is still next to the player board, and once revealed, it is removed from your hand and flips over, indicating that you have made it visible to others.
- In this top-down 2d implementation, it's a bit difficult to see where the plugs are connected. I would love to see a yellow cable line connecting the plugs (this can be a simple graphic overlay) so that it's super clear at a glance which appliances are connected.
- The phrasing "You must select a plug to receive 1⚡ from another plug" is a bit confusing. I suggest rewording it to: "You must select a plug. It will receive 1⚡ from the other plug."
- The card icons in the opponent hand are very small, and I think could be a bit larger.
That's it, everything else is wonderful! So many great little details too, like how the spy cards are arranged on the back side so players think they're hidden, but on the front side they are set apart so you can easily distinguish them. Top notch. • Cal é o teu navegador?
Google Chrome v125
-
• Qué parte das regras non se cumpriron na adaptación da BGA?
Great work overall, this is a super smooth and intuitive interface. Really nice!
Some thoughts:
- In the real game I encourage players to keep Agenda cards in their hand because otherwise I find they often forget that they have them. In fact, in this implementation, the button to reveal is a bit hard to find initially, and players will likely forget that they even CAN reveal. Players are much more focused on the trick-taking and choosing a card to play, rather than thinking about revealing. So, since they're staring at their hand anyway, I suggest Agenda cards could go in hand here too, with a "reveal" button (as well as a "rotate" button so you can rotate the agenda even if you don't reveal) appearing above the Agenda card at the start of your turn. The face-down Agenda is still next to the player board, and once revealed, it is removed from your hand and flips over, indicating that you have made it visible to others.
- In this top-down 2d implementation, it's a bit difficult to see where the plugs are connected. I would love to see a yellow cable line connecting the plugs (this can be a simple graphic overlay) so that it's super clear at a glance which appliances are connected.
- The phrasing "You must select a plug to receive 1⚡ from another plug" is a bit confusing. I suggest rewording it to: "You must select a plug. It will receive 1⚡ from the other plug."
- The card icons in the opponent hand are very small, and I think could be a bit larger.
That's it, everything else is wonderful! So many great little details too, like how the spy cards are arranged on the back side so players think they're hidden, but on the front side they are set apart so you can easily distinguish them. Top notch. -
• é visible a violación das regras na repetición? Se o é, en que número de movemento?
• Cal é o teu navegador?
Google Chrome v125
-
• Qué acción de xogo querías realizar?
Great work overall, this is a super smooth and intuitive interface. Really nice!
Some thoughts:
- In the real game I encourage players to keep Agenda cards in their hand because otherwise I find they often forget that they have them. In fact, in this implementation, the button to reveal is a bit hard to find initially, and players will likely forget that they even CAN reveal. Players are much more focused on the trick-taking and choosing a card to play, rather than thinking about revealing. So, since they're staring at their hand anyway, I suggest Agenda cards could go in hand here too, with a "reveal" button (as well as a "rotate" button so you can rotate the agenda even if you don't reveal) appearing above the Agenda card at the start of your turn. The face-down Agenda is still next to the player board, and once revealed, it is removed from your hand and flips over, indicating that you have made it visible to others.
- In this top-down 2d implementation, it's a bit difficult to see where the plugs are connected. I would love to see a yellow cable line connecting the plugs (this can be a simple graphic overlay) so that it's super clear at a glance which appliances are connected.
- The phrasing "You must select a plug to receive 1⚡ from another plug" is a bit confusing. I suggest rewording it to: "You must select a plug. It will receive 1⚡ from the other plug."
- The card icons in the opponent hand are very small, and I think could be a bit larger.
That's it, everything else is wonderful! So many great little details too, like how the spy cards are arranged on the back side so players think they're hidden, but on the front side they are set apart so you can easily distinguish them. Top notch. -
• Qué é o que tratache de facer para activar esta acción do xogo?
-
• Qué sucedeu cando o fixeche (a mensaxe de erro, mensaxe na barra de estado do xogo, ...)?
• Cal é o teu navegador?
Google Chrome v125
-
• En que paso do xogo ocorreu o problema (cal foi a instrucción actual do xogo)?
Great work overall, this is a super smooth and intuitive interface. Really nice!
Some thoughts:
- In the real game I encourage players to keep Agenda cards in their hand because otherwise I find they often forget that they have them. In fact, in this implementation, the button to reveal is a bit hard to find initially, and players will likely forget that they even CAN reveal. Players are much more focused on the trick-taking and choosing a card to play, rather than thinking about revealing. So, since they're staring at their hand anyway, I suggest Agenda cards could go in hand here too, with a "reveal" button (as well as a "rotate" button so you can rotate the agenda even if you don't reveal) appearing above the Agenda card at the start of your turn. The face-down Agenda is still next to the player board, and once revealed, it is removed from your hand and flips over, indicating that you have made it visible to others.
- In this top-down 2d implementation, it's a bit difficult to see where the plugs are connected. I would love to see a yellow cable line connecting the plugs (this can be a simple graphic overlay) so that it's super clear at a glance which appliances are connected.
- The phrasing "You must select a plug to receive 1⚡ from another plug" is a bit confusing. I suggest rewording it to: "You must select a plug. It will receive 1⚡ from the other plug."
- The card icons in the opponent hand are very small, and I think could be a bit larger.
That's it, everything else is wonderful! So many great little details too, like how the spy cards are arranged on the back side so players think they're hidden, but on the front side they are set apart so you can easily distinguish them. Top notch. -
• Qué sucedeu cando tratache de facer unha acción de xogo (mensaxe de erro, mensaxe na barra de estado do xogo, ...)?
• Cal é o teu navegador?
Google Chrome v125
-
• Por favor, describe o problema de visualización. Se tes un pantallazo deste erro (boa práctica), podes usar Imgur.com para subilo e copiar/pegar a ligazón aquí.
Great work overall, this is a super smooth and intuitive interface. Really nice!
Some thoughts:
- In the real game I encourage players to keep Agenda cards in their hand because otherwise I find they often forget that they have them. In fact, in this implementation, the button to reveal is a bit hard to find initially, and players will likely forget that they even CAN reveal. Players are much more focused on the trick-taking and choosing a card to play, rather than thinking about revealing. So, since they're staring at their hand anyway, I suggest Agenda cards could go in hand here too, with a "reveal" button (as well as a "rotate" button so you can rotate the agenda even if you don't reveal) appearing above the Agenda card at the start of your turn. The face-down Agenda is still next to the player board, and once revealed, it is removed from your hand and flips over, indicating that you have made it visible to others.
- In this top-down 2d implementation, it's a bit difficult to see where the plugs are connected. I would love to see a yellow cable line connecting the plugs (this can be a simple graphic overlay) so that it's super clear at a glance which appliances are connected.
- The phrasing "You must select a plug to receive 1⚡ from another plug" is a bit confusing. I suggest rewording it to: "You must select a plug. It will receive 1⚡ from the other plug."
- The card icons in the opponent hand are very small, and I think could be a bit larger.
That's it, everything else is wonderful! So many great little details too, like how the spy cards are arranged on the back side so players think they're hidden, but on the front side they are set apart so you can easily distinguish them. Top notch. • Cal é o teu navegador?
Google Chrome v125
-
• Por favor, copia/pega o texto amosado en inglés no canto do teu idioma. Se tes un pantallazo deste erro (boa práctica), podes usar Imgur.com para subilo e copiar/pegar a ligazón aquí.
Great work overall, this is a super smooth and intuitive interface. Really nice!
Some thoughts:
- In the real game I encourage players to keep Agenda cards in their hand because otherwise I find they often forget that they have them. In fact, in this implementation, the button to reveal is a bit hard to find initially, and players will likely forget that they even CAN reveal. Players are much more focused on the trick-taking and choosing a card to play, rather than thinking about revealing. So, since they're staring at their hand anyway, I suggest Agenda cards could go in hand here too, with a "reveal" button (as well as a "rotate" button so you can rotate the agenda even if you don't reveal) appearing above the Agenda card at the start of your turn. The face-down Agenda is still next to the player board, and once revealed, it is removed from your hand and flips over, indicating that you have made it visible to others.
- In this top-down 2d implementation, it's a bit difficult to see where the plugs are connected. I would love to see a yellow cable line connecting the plugs (this can be a simple graphic overlay) so that it's super clear at a glance which appliances are connected.
- The phrasing "You must select a plug to receive 1⚡ from another plug" is a bit confusing. I suggest rewording it to: "You must select a plug. It will receive 1⚡ from the other plug."
- The card icons in the opponent hand are very small, and I think could be a bit larger.
That's it, everything else is wonderful! So many great little details too, like how the spy cards are arranged on the back side so players think they're hidden, but on the front side they are set apart so you can easily distinguish them. Top notch. -
• É este o texto dispoñible no sistema de tradución? Se é así, foi traducido fai máis de 24 horas?
• Cal é o teu navegador?
Google Chrome v125
-
• Por favor explica a túa suxestión de maneira precisa e concisa para que sexa o máis sinxelo posible entender o que queres dicir.
Great work overall, this is a super smooth and intuitive interface. Really nice!
Some thoughts:
- In the real game I encourage players to keep Agenda cards in their hand because otherwise I find they often forget that they have them. In fact, in this implementation, the button to reveal is a bit hard to find initially, and players will likely forget that they even CAN reveal. Players are much more focused on the trick-taking and choosing a card to play, rather than thinking about revealing. So, since they're staring at their hand anyway, I suggest Agenda cards could go in hand here too, with a "reveal" button (as well as a "rotate" button so you can rotate the agenda even if you don't reveal) appearing above the Agenda card at the start of your turn. The face-down Agenda is still next to the player board, and once revealed, it is removed from your hand and flips over, indicating that you have made it visible to others.
- In this top-down 2d implementation, it's a bit difficult to see where the plugs are connected. I would love to see a yellow cable line connecting the plugs (this can be a simple graphic overlay) so that it's super clear at a glance which appliances are connected.
- The phrasing "You must select a plug to receive 1⚡ from another plug" is a bit confusing. I suggest rewording it to: "You must select a plug. It will receive 1⚡ from the other plug."
- The card icons in the opponent hand are very small, and I think could be a bit larger.
That's it, everything else is wonderful! So many great little details too, like how the spy cards are arranged on the back side so players think they're hidden, but on the front side they are set apart so you can easily distinguish them. Top notch. • Cal é o teu navegador?
Google Chrome v125
Historial de informes
However, I agree agenda cards can be easily overlooked, so I moved the player's agenda cards.
- Added red lines instead, as the plug icon I received depicts cables as red dots.
- Changed the transfer state text.
- Slightly enlarged the card icons. If enlarged further, the back card row splits.
Thanks for the feedback!
However I think the agenda/player boards could be tweaked slightly. I did like that you could see your player board and agenda marker alongside the other players. In mobile, currently your points area is just an empty box (i.imgur.com/gFpowSX.jpeg) which is very odd. I do like seeing the Agenda card and being able to rotate it, but the ? symbol is also a bit confusing.
Here's my suggestion: player board goes back to the top right next to all players, so you can easily see all player boards together. While you agenda is hidden, your agenda is next to your hand, and top right the agenda is flipped down. This indicates that your agenda is still hidden but you can see what it is (i.imgur.com/sN82WmE.png).
When you reveal your agenda, the card moves from your hand to the top right, gone from your hand and now revealed for everyone (i.imgur.com/TFTxPnF.png).
This seems like the best of all worlds!
Thanks for the amazing work on this.
Engade a este informe
- Outro DI de mesa / ID de movemento
- Premer F5 resolveu o problema?
- Apareceu o problema varias veces? Tódalas veces? Aleatoriamente?
- Se tes un pantallazo deste erro (boa práctica), podes usar Imgur.com para subilo e copiar/pegar a ligazón aquí.
