Todos os informes
Informes de riichimahjong_displayed
#111968: "Game did not realize a way to win"
notabug: Isto non é un erro
3
Sobre qué é este informe?
Qué aconteceu? Por favor selecciona debaixo
Regras: unha regra do xogo non foi respectada
Descrición detallada
• Qué parte das regras non se cumpriron na adaptación da BGA?
green dragon pon, had concealed 5 circle meld, 6 circle, two 7 circle, one 8 circle. person to my right drops a 7 circle, game only recognizes the possible pon, but it should be a win because the 7 completes the sequence meld 5 6 7 and the other two 7s are the pair/eyes.• é visible a violación das regras na repetición? Se o é, en que número de movemento?
Move 161• Cal é o teu navegador?
Mozilla v5
Historial de informes
22. Xan 2024 22:40 • gilthe • Os desenvolvedores requiren máis información para reproducir este erro:
I can't see the replay yet because the game is ongoing, but the most common scenario is that you are in Furiten: what this means is that you cannot win by Ron (only by Tsumo). It happens whenever there is a winning tile in your discard pile. In your case, 6 circle is a winning tile (567, 678, 55, GGG, ???) as are 7 circle (555, 678, 77, GGG, ???) and 9 circle (567, 789, 55, GGG, ???). Might this be the reason?
Cheers,
gilthe
Cheers,
gilthe
11. Mar 2024 19:58 • fanofspurss • Os desenvolvedores requiren máis información para reproducir este erro:
Japanese (Riichi) Mahjong #478332526
I have 123 bamboo, 5555 bamboo , 567 circles (opened)
In my hand, I have 34 characters and 44 bamboo
on my turn I draw 5 to complete 345 characters but I can't win the game. any idea why?
I have 1 bamboo in my discard pile. Is this considered as furiten as well?
I have 123 bamboo, 5555 bamboo , 567 circles (opened)
In my hand, I have 34 characters and 44 bamboo
on my turn I draw 5 to complete 345 characters but I can't win the game. any idea why?
I have 1 bamboo in my discard pile. Is this considered as furiten as well?
11. Mar 2024 22:01 • gilthe • Os desenvolvedores requiren máis información para reproducir este erro:
No, it's not Furiten, it's because this open hand has no Yaku. In Japanese Mahjong, you need at least one Yaku to declare a win. The most common Yaku are Riichi, all Simples (only 2-8 tiles, Tanyao), and No-points-hand (closed only, Pinfu), see documentation here on BGA or riichi.wiki/List_of_yaku .
One pattern to avoid is an open straight (Chi) featuring a terminal (1 or 9) tile since this eliminates all of these common Yaku along with many others. The most common Yaku to combine such a pattern with would be a Pon of dragons or seat/round wind.
One pattern to avoid is an open straight (Chi) featuring a terminal (1 or 9) tile since this eliminates all of these common Yaku along with many others. The most common Yaku to combine such a pattern with would be a Pon of dragons or seat/round wind.
15. Mar 2025 20:35 • Kuma74 • Os desenvolvedores requiren máis información para reproducir este erro:
Original bug is valid at time of filing:
in-Hand: 5556778p Open: Green Dragon Pon, 234p (p=pin, dots).
Move 158~161 you are offered a 7p pon,
If you took that 7: 55567778; -> 555 678 77.
Your explanation is wrong, but your complaint is correct. You had Half-flush and Green Dragon yaku; and a valid 14 tile completed hand. You should have been offered Ron.
in-Hand: 5556778p Open: Green Dragon Pon, 234p (p=pin, dots).
Move 158~161 you are offered a 7p pon,
If you took that 7: 55567778; -> 555 678 77.
Your explanation is wrong, but your complaint is correct. You had Half-flush and Green Dragon yaku; and a valid 14 tile completed hand. You should have been offered Ron.
15. Mar 2025 20:37 • Kuma74 • Os desenvolvedores requiren máis información para reproducir este erro:
nvmd I'm a dumbbutt 1st discard is 9p and wait is 679p X3;.
20. Xul 2025 4:14 • bamf226 • Os desenvolvedores requiren máis información para reproducir este erro:
table 655624123
in-hand 23 bamboo, pair of west
open pons: 1 character, 1 dot, 9 dot
left player discards 1 bamboo for ron (outside hand)
no 1 bamboo in discard
in-hand 23 bamboo, pair of west
open pons: 1 character, 1 dot, 9 dot
left player discards 1 bamboo for ron (outside hand)
no 1 bamboo in discard
20. Xul 2025 11:45 • gilthe • Isto non é un erro:
Looks like you have 4-Bamboo in discard.
The Furiten rule is a bit confusing because it applies to any tile that completes the hand irrespective of its values. So while it is true that you need 1-Bamboo to complete a mixed outside hand, both the 1- and 4-Bamboo tiles count against you when it comes to Furiten.
Here's the quote from riichi.wiki/Furiten :
Note that it does not matter if the hand was unable to win with the discarded/skipped tile because the hand wouldn't have yaku. So long as the tile would complete a valid 14 tile shape, it counts for furiten.
Hope that clarifies it.
The Furiten rule is a bit confusing because it applies to any tile that completes the hand irrespective of its values. So while it is true that you need 1-Bamboo to complete a mixed outside hand, both the 1- and 4-Bamboo tiles count against you when it comes to Furiten.
Here's the quote from riichi.wiki/Furiten :
Note that it does not matter if the hand was unable to win with the discarded/skipped tile because the hand wouldn't have yaku. So long as the tile would complete a valid 14 tile shape, it counts for furiten.
Hope that clarifies it.
Engade a este informe
Por favor engade aquí calquera cousa que sexa relevante para reproducir este erro ou entender a túa suxestión:
- Outro DI de mesa / ID de movemento
- Premer F5 resolveu o problema?
- Apareceu o problema varias veces? Tódalas veces? Aleatoriamente?
- Se tes un pantallazo deste erro (boa práctica), podes usar Imgur.com para subilo e copiar/pegar a ligazón aquí.
